| Round 1 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 1 | Thirty Five | Peyton Manning | QB01 |
| 2 | Hess's Hogs | LaDainian Tomlinson | RB01 |
| 3 | Stumps | Shaun Alexander | RB02 |
| 4 | Golden Boys | Daunte Culpepper | QB02 |
| 5 | Team Repeat | Julius Jones | RB03 |
| 6 | Superstars | Edgerrin James | RB04 |
| 7 | Superbowl Bound | Willis McGahee | RB05 |
| 8 | Team Whitey | Priest Holmes | RB06 |
| 9 | Drive-By Snowman | Corey Dillon | RB07 |
| 10 | Iron City Maulers | Deuce McAllister | RB08 |
| 11 | Special Ed | Randy Moss | WR01 |
| 12 | Wise Guys | Clinton Portis | RB09 |
| Round 2 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 13 | Wise Guys | Terrell Owens | WR02 |
| 14 | Special Ed | Jamal Lewis | RB10 |
| 15 | Iron City Maulers | Domanick Davis | RB11 |
| 16 | Drive-By Snowman | Steven Jackson | RB12 |
| 17 | Team Whitey | Donovan McNabb | QB03 |
| 18 | Superbowl Bound | Kevin Jones | RB13 |
| 19 | Superstars | Rudi Johnson | RB14 |
| 20 | Team Repeat | Ahman Green | RB15 |
| 21 | Golden Boys | LaMont Jordan | RB16 |
| 22 | Stumps | Tiki Barber | RB17 |
| 23 | Hess's Hogs | Curtis Martin | RB18 |
| 24 | Thirty Five | Brian Westbrook | RB19 |
| Round 3 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 25 | Superbowl Bound | Brett Favre | QB04 |
| 26 | Thirty Five | Fred Taylor | RB20 |
| 27 | Hess's Hogs | Marc Bulger | QB05 |
| 28 | Stumps | Chad Johnson | WR03 |
| 29 | Team Whitey | Torry Holt | WR04 |
| 30 | Special Ed | Kerry Collins | QB06 |
| 31 | Superstars | Mike Anderson | RB21 |
| 32 | Drive-By Snowman | Marvin Harrison | WR05 |
| 33 | Wise Guys | Trent Green | QB07 |
| 34 | Iron City Maulers | Javon Walker | WR06 |
| 35 | Team Repeat | Reggie Wayne | WR07 |
| 36 | Golden Boys | Joe Horn | WR08 |
| Round 4 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 37 | Golden Boys | Larry Johnson | RB22 |
| 38 | Team Repeat | Nate Burleson | WR09 |
| 39 | Iron City Maulers | Steve Smith | WR10 |
| 40 | Wise Guys | Carnell Williams | RB23 |
| 41 | Drive-By Snowman | Jake Delhomme | QB08 |
| 42 | Superstars | Darrell Jackson | WR11 |
| 43 | Special Ed | J.J. Arrington | RB24 |
| 44 | Team Whitey | Kevan Barlow | RB25 |
| 45 | Stumps | Andre Johnson | WR12 |
| 46 | Hess's Hogs | Michael Clayton | WR13 |
| 47 | Thirty Five | Hines Ward | WR14 |
| 48 | Superbowl Bound | Roy Williams | WR15 |
| Round 5 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 49 | Drive-By Snowman | Deion Branch | WR16 |
| 50 | Superstars | Warrick Dunn | RB26 |
| 51 | Thirty Five | Tony Gonzalez | WR17 |
| 52 | Stumps | Jake Plummer | QB09 |
| 53 | Team Whitey | Ronnie Brown | RB27 |
| 54 | Wise Guys | Anquan Boldin | WR18 |
| 55 | Iron City Maulers | Tom Brady | QB10 |
| 56 | Superbowl Bound | Donald Driver | WR19 |
| 57 | Team Repeat | Carson Palmer | QB11 |
| 58 | Hess's Hogs | Drew Bennett | WR20 |
| 59 | Golden Boys | Laveranues Coles | WR21 |
| 60 | Special Ed | Antonio Gates | WR22 |
| Round 6 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 61 | Special Ed | Chris Brown | RB28 |
| 62 | Golden Boys | Isaac Bruce | WR23 |
| 63 | Hess's Hogs | Matt Hasselbeck | QB12 |
| 64 | Team Repeat | David Akers | PK01 |
| 65 | Superbowl Bound | DeShaun Foster | RB29 |
| 66 | Iron City Maulers | Kurt Warner | QB13 |
| 67 | Wise Guys | Cedric Benson | RB30 |
| 68 | Team Whitey | Chris Chambers | WR24 |
| 69 | Stumps | Michael Bennett | RB31 |
| 70 | Thirty Five | Drew Brees | QB14 |
| 71 | Superstars | Aaron Brooks | QB15 |
| 72 | Drive-By Snowman | Brian Griese | QB16 |
| Round 7 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 73 | Wise Guys | Ashley Lelie | WR25 |
| 74 | Golden Boys | Chester Taylor | RB32 |
| 75 | Superbowl Bound | Ricky Williams | RB33 |
| 76 | Stumps | Larry Fitzgerald | WR26 |
| 77 | Iron City Maulers | Willie Parker | RB34 |
| 78 | Special Ed | Travis Henry | RB35 |
| 79 | Thirty Five | Plaxico Burress | WR27 |
| 80 | Superstars | Michael Vick | QB17 |
| 81 | Hess's Hogs | Thomas Jones | RB36 |
| 82 | Team Repeat | Mewelde Moore | RB37 |
| 83 | Drive-By Snowman | Ed Reed | DF01 |
| 84 | Team Whitey | Jerry Porter | WR28 |
| Round 8 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 85 | Team Whitey | Julius Peppers | DF02 |
| 86 | Drive-By Snowman | Marshall Faulk | RB38 |
| 87 | Team Repeat | Chad Pennington | QB18 |
| 88 | Hess's Hogs | Tatum Bell | RB39 |
| 89 | Superstars | Derrick Mason | WR29 |
| 90 | Thirty Five | Lee Suggs | RB40 |
| 91 | Special Ed | Muhsin Muhammad | WR30 |
| 92 | Iron City Maulers | Byron Leftwich | QB19 |
| 93 | Stumps | Joey Harrington | QB20 |
| 94 | Superbowl Bound | Santana Moss | WR31 |
| 95 | Golden Boys | Stephen Davis | RB41 |
| 96 | Wise Guys | Steve McNair | QB21 |
| Round 9 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 97 | Thirty Five | Mike Vanderjagt | PK02 |
| 98 | Hess's Hogs | Rod Smith | WR32 |
| 99 | Stumps | Simeon Rice | DF03 |
| 100 | Golden Boys | Jimmy Smith | WR33 |
| 101 | Special Ed | Sean Taylor | DF04 |
| 102 | Superstars | Eddie Kennison | WR34 |
| 103 | Team Repeat | Duce Staley | RB42 |
| 104 | Team Whitey | Eric Moulds | WR35 |
| 105 | Iron City Maulers | Jerome Bettis | RB43 |
| 106 | Drive-By Snowman | T.J. Houshmandzadeh | WR36 |
| 107 | Superbowl Bound | Brandon Stokley | WR37 |
| 108 | Wise Guys | Jason Elam | PK03 |
| Round 10 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 109 | Wise Guys | Dwight Freeney | DF05 |
| 110 | Superbowl Bound | Eli Manning | QB22 |
| 111 | Drive-By Snowman | Marcel Shipp | RB44 |
| 112 | Iron City Maulers | Troy Polamalu | DF06 |
| 113 | Team Whitey | Matt Stover | PK04 |
| 114 | Team Repeat | Keyshawn Johnson | WR38 |
| 115 | Superstars | DeMarcus Ware | DF07 |
| 116 | Special Ed | Drew Bledsoe | QB23 |
| 117 | Golden Boys | Billy Volek | QB24 |
| 118 | Stumps | John Abraham | DF08 |
| 119 | Hess's Hogs | David Carr | QB25 |
| 120 | Thirty Five | Mike Williams | WR39 |
| Round 11 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 121 | Superbowl Bound | Adam Vinatieri | PK05 |
| 122 | Thirty Five | LaBrandon Toefield | RB45 |
| 123 | Hess's Hogs | Lee Evans | WR40 |
| 124 | Stumps | Jeff Wilkins | PK06 |
| 125 | Team Whitey | Tim Rattay | QB26 |
| 126 | Special Ed | Rodney Harrison | DF09 |
| 127 | Superstars | Ryan Longwell | PK07 |
| 128 | Drive-By Snowman | John Kasay | PK08 |
| 129 | Wise Guys | Trent Dilfer | QB27 |
| 130 | Iron City Maulers | Sebastian Janikowski | PK09 |
| 131 | Team Repeat | Terrence McGee | DF10 |
| 132 | Golden Boys | Shayne Graham | PK10 |
| Round 12 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 133 | Golden Boys | Gus Frerotte | QB28 |
| 134 | Team Repeat | Terrell Suggs | DF11 |
| 135 | Iron City Maulers | Bertrand Berry | DF12 |
| 136 | Wise Guys | Shawn Springs | DF13 |
| 137 | Drive-By Snowman | Darren Sharper | DF14 |
| 138 | Superstars | Ben Roethlisberger | QB29 |
| 139 | Special Ed | Jason Hanson | PK11 |
| 140 | Team Whitey | Michael Strahan | DF15 |
| 141 | Stumps | Jason Taylor | DF16 |
| 142 | Hess's Hogs | Paul Edinger | PK12 |
| 143 | Thirty Five | Kabeer Gbaja-Biamila | DF17 |
| 144 | Superbowl Bound | Todd Peterson | PK13 |
| Round 13 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 145 | Drive-By Snowman | Kyle Orton | QB30 |
| 146 | Superstars | Greg Lewis | WR41 |
| 147 | Thirty Five | Mike Nugent | PK14 |
| 148 | Stumps | Charles Grant | DF18 |
| 149 | Team Whitey | Patrick Ramsey | QB31 |
| 150 | Wise Guys | Kevin Williams | DF19 |
| 151 | Iron City Maulers | Antonio Bryant | WR42 |
| 152 | Superbowl Bound | LaVar Arrington | DF20 |
| 153 | Team Repeat | Amani Toomer | WR43 |
| 154 | Hess's Hogs | Patrick Kerney | DF21 |
| 155 | Golden Boys | Ken Lucas | DF22 |
| 156 | Special Ed | Kevin Curtis | WR44 |
| Round 14 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 157 | Special Ed | Roy Williams | DF23 |
| 158 | Golden Boys | Chris McAlister | DF24 |
| 159 | Hess's Hogs | Lito Sheppard | DF25 |
| 160 | Team Repeat | Ronde Barber | DF26 |
| 161 | Superbowl Bound | Darren Howard | DF27 |
| 162 | Iron City Maulers | Nate Clements | DF28 |
| 163 | Wise Guys | Charles Rogers | WR45 |
| 164 | Team Whitey | T.J. Duckett | RB46 |
| 165 | Stumps | J.P. Losman | QB32 |
| 166 | Thirty Five | Dunta Robinson | DF29 |
| 167 | Superstars | John Carney | PK15 |
| 168 | Drive-By Snowman | Adewale Ogunleye | DF30 |
| Round 15 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 169 | Wise Guys | Ladell Betts | RB47 |
| 170 | Golden Boys | Corey Chavous | DF31 |
| 171 | Superbowl Bound | Takeo Spikes | DF32 |
| 172 | Stumps | Keenan McCardell | WR46 |
| 173 | Iron City Maulers | Jeff Reed | PK16 |
| 174 | Special Ed | Brian Dawkins | DF33 |
| 175 | Thirty Five | Sammy Knight | DF34 |
| 176 | Superstars | Champ Bailey | DF35 |
| 177 | Hess's Hogs | Josh Brown | PK17 |
| 178 | Team Repeat | Carlos Rogers | DF36 |
| 179 | Drive-By Snowman | Neil Rackers | PK18 |
| 180 | Team Whitey | Robert Mathis | DF37 |
| Round 16 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 181 | Team Whitey | Reggie Hayward | DF38 |
| 182 | Drive-By Snowman | Bobby Engram | WR47 |
| 183 | Team Repeat | Lawrence Tynes | PK19 |
| 184 | Hess's Hogs | James Hall | DF39 |
| 185 | Superstars | Lawyer Milloy | DF40 |
| 186 | Thirty Five | Pacman Jones | DF41 |
| 187 | Special Ed | Jose Cortez | PK20 |
| 188 | Iron City Maulers | Ronald Curry | WR48 |
| 189 | Stumps | Nate Kaeding | PK21 |
| 190 | Superbowl Bound | Shaun Ellis | DF42 |
| 191 | Golden Boys | Deion Sanders | DF43 |
| 192 | Wise Guys | John Hall | PK22 |
| Round 17 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 193 | Thirty Five | Kyle Boller | QB33 |
| 194 | Hess's Hogs | Aaron Schobel | DF44 |
| 195 | Stumps | Brandon Jacobs | RB48 |
| 196 | Golden Boys | Phil Dawson | PK23 |
| 197 | Special Ed | Mark Brunell | QB34 |
| 198 | Superstars | Derrick Brooks | DF45 |
| 199 | Team Repeat | Jon Kitna | QB35 |
| 200 | Team Whitey | Kris Brown | PK24 |
| 201 | Iron City Maulers | James Farrior | DF46 |
| 202 | Drive-By Snowman | Phillip Buchanon | DF47 |
| 203 | Superbowl Bound | Alex Smith | QB36 |
| 204 | Wise Guys | Dante Hall | WR49 |